Is your next tenant a dream or a disaster? Here’s how to find out.
Finding the perfect tenant is like solving a puzzle. You need the right pieces like reliable income, a clean rental history, and a responsible attitude to make it fit. But here’s the kicker: background checks alone won’t tell you everything.
So, how do you go beyond the basics to pick the best renter? We’ll walk you through the essential strategies to make tenant screening easier, smarter, and way less stressful. And if you're a property manager, you’ll see exactly where you fit in to make this process seamless.
Let’s dive into the five key strategies that take tenant screening from guesswork to science.
1. Define Your Screening Criteria (And Stick to It)
Before you even start reviewing applications, get clear on what makes an ideal tenant for your property. Creating a screening checklist keeps you consistent and protects you from legal trouble. Here’s what to include:
Income Stability: A good rule of thumb? Monthly income should be at least three times the rent. Ask for pay stubs, tax returns, or bank statements to verify.
Employment History: A steady job is a great sign. Frequent job changes? That might be a red flag.
Rental History: Previous landlords can tell you a lot. Was rent paid on time? Any complaints from neighbors?
Credit Score: A credit check gives insight into financial habits. Late payments or maxed-out credit cards could mean trouble.
Background Check: While past mistakes don’t always predict future behavior, a history of evictions or criminal activity might be worth a second look.
Property managers help landlords stay compliant by ensuring these criteria align with Fair Housing Laws and other regulations. They also standardize the process so no applicant is unfairly excluded.
2. Use Pre-Screening to Save Time
Why waste time reviewing applications that don’t fit your criteria? Pre-screening helps you weed out unqualified applicants before they apply. Here’s how:
Be Transparent in Your Listing: Clearly state rent price, pet policies, income requirements, and anything else that matters. This prevents back-and-forth with renters who don’t qualify.
Ask a Few Key Questions Upfront: Before scheduling a showing, ask about employment, move-in timeline, and rental history. If answers don’t align with your requirements, no need to move forward.
Set Up a Short Phone Call: A quick chat can reveal a lot—communication skills, honesty, and how serious they are about renting.
For property managers, pre-screening means fewer bad applications, less wasted time, and better tenants from the start.
3. Dig Deeper With Reference Checks
Applications and credit reports only tell part of the story. To get the full picture, talk to people who know the applicant best:
Call Previous Landlords: Ask if rent was paid on time, if there were any complaints, and if they’d rent to them again.
Verify Employment: A simple call to an employer can confirm job stability and income.
Check Personal References: While friends might be biased, long-term colleagues or mentors can offer valuable insights.
Property managers often have established processes and scripts for these calls, ensuring you get honest and useful information.
4. Leverage Technology for Smarter Screening
The right tools make tenant screening faster and more reliable. Consider using online platforms that offer:
Instant Credit & Background Checks: Services like TransUnion and RentPrep provide instant reports so you don’t have to wait.
Automated Income Verification: Some tools connect directly to a tenant’s bank account (with permission) to confirm income without paperwork.
Digital Applications: Online applications streamline the process and keep everything organized.
Property managers have access to industry-leading screening tools, saving landlords from the hassle of sorting through paperwork and verifying information manually.
5. Trust Your Gut (But Back It Up With Data)
Sometimes, everything looks perfect on paper, but something feels off. Maybe they hesitate when answering basic questions or seem too eager to rush the process.
Red flags to watch for:
Overeagerness to Pay in Cash: Could indicate illegal activities or an attempt to hide income sources.
Refusal to Provide References: If they “can’t remember” their last landlord’s contact info, that’s a problem.
History of Moving Frequently: Job relocations happen, but consistent short-term stays might signal instability.
While intuition plays a role, always rely on concrete screening steps to support your decision.
Final Thoughts: Tenant Screening Made Easy
Tenant screening doesn’t have to be complicated. You can set clear criteria, pre-screen applicants, check references, use technology, and trust – but verify – your gut feeling and still get great tenants with little stress.
If you want to use a property manager, get in touch with the expert team at Property Sourced Rentals. We can do all of this for you – thus providing you with quality renters while also making sure that you are within the law. Contact us today to discuss creating a strategy for you.
There is always that perfect tenant out there. Now you have the tools to find them.
Comments